Rated 5.0 on Google One fixed monthly fee, agreed in writing FreeAgent or Xero included Brixton, by appointment Looking after South London businesses since 2015

Do I need an accountant, or can you handle it yourself?

Plenty of people file their own return perfectly well, and we will say so. What changes the answer is rarely the size of the income; it is how many moving parts the year has and how much of your head the paperwork takes up.

Published 5 November 2026

6 min read

Ryan Morton, FMAAT, Founder and Principal Accountant

Do I need an accountant is the question we get asked most often by people who have not hired one yet, usually in January, usually at about nine in the evening. The honest answer is that nobody is required to have one. HMRC built Self Assessment for individuals to file themselves, and a lot of people do it without drama.

Our view, after ten years of taking these calls in Brixton, is that the right question is a different one. It is not how complicated your tax is. It is how many things in your year now depend on you remembering them, and what happens to the rest of your work when one of them goes wrong.

Here is how we think about it, including the cases where we tell people to carry on as they are.

When filing it yourself works fine

One source of income, a handful of expenses, no VAT, no company, no staff. You keep the invoices in a folder, the bank statements agree with them, and once a year you sit down and type the numbers into HMRC’s online service. That takes an evening, not a weekend, and you will not learn anything from paying someone to do it for you.

If your self-employed income before expenses is £1,000 or less in the year, you may not need to report it at all under the trading allowance. Worth checking before you do anything else.

The people in this group who get into trouble are not the ones who file their own return. They are the ones who never set the money aside. The tax is real whoever presses the button, and the bill lands on 31 January along with a payment on account you were not expecting. If you are managing your own return, open a second bank account and move a percentage over every time you get paid. That single habit prevents most of the panic we hear about.

The point where the year gets crowded

Things change when the year stops having one shape. A company with its own filing dates. Payroll running monthly. VAT once you are near the £90,000 threshold on a rolling twelve months, which creeps up on people who only look at their figures in April. A contract that needs an IR35 view before you sign it. Your own return on top of all of it.

None of these is hard on its own. Together they are a calendar, and the calendar does not care that you have a show to install or a client who moved the deadline. A company that files its accounts late gets a penalty that grows the longer it waits, and nobody rings you first.

This is the honest line for us. The work is not beyond you. The remembering is what costs you, and it costs you at exactly the times of year when you are busiest. That is when people start looking for accountants for small businesses rather than wondering whether they technically need one.

Making Tax Digital changes the maths

The old arrangement, where you ignored the paperwork for eleven months and dealt with it in one sitting, is ending for sole traders and landlords. From 6 April 2026, anyone with qualifying income from self-employment and property over £50,000 has to use HMRC‘s Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, keeping digital records and sending quarterly updates. The threshold steps down to £30,000 from April 2027 and £20,000 from April 2028.

Qualifying income is turnover before expenses, taken from the return you filed the year before, so a sole trader billing £55,000 and spending half of it is in scope. HMRC has said it will not issue penalty points for late quarterly updates in the first year, but the penalties for a late return or late payment still stand.

Practically, that means software and a routine rather than a shoebox. If you were already on FreeAgent or Xero with the bank feed connected, very little changes. If you were not, the yearly sit-down becomes four smaller ones, and the question of whether you want to own that is worth answering before September rather than after.

What you are actually buying

Most people picture an accountant as someone who fills in a form. That part is maybe a tenth of it. What you are buying is somebody watching the dates on your behalf and telling you what is coming before it arrives.

An example from the practice. An artist came to us in a bad state during lockdown, convinced she had made a mess of her tax because the paintings had started selling far better than she expected. It turned out to be less bad than she feared. We moved her from an accidental sole trade into a limited company, handled the registrations, set up the software and showed her the routine. Nothing clever happened. Somebody just told her where she stood, which was the thing she could not get from reading forum threads at midnight.

The other half of it is having a person to ring. Whether to register for VAT early, what you can safely take out as dividends, whether this contract sits inside off-payroll working. Those are five-minute conversations that are expensive to get wrong and cheap to ask about, as long as asking is included in what you pay.

How to judge it for yourself

Three questions we would ask if you rang us undecided.

  • How many deadlines does your year have? One is manageable. Five or six, with payroll monthly and VAT quarterly, is a job.
  • When did you last look at your figures? If the answer is “when I did last year’s return”, you are making decisions about pricing and hiring on guesswork.
  • What does the admin cost you? Not in money. In the Sunday evenings, and in the work you did not take because the paperwork was behind.

If you are a sole trader with one client and simple costs, carry on. If you have a company, staff, VAT, or a contract starting next month and nothing set up, the arithmetic goes the other way quickly. And if you are somewhere in between, the useful move is to ask rather than to guess, which costs nothing.

Common questions

Do I need an accountant by law to run a limited company?

No. Company directors can prepare and file their own accounts and corporation tax return. What the law does require is that the filings are correct and on time, and that the records behind them are kept. Most directors hand it over because the dates stack up rather than because the rules say they must.

Do I need an accountant if I only earn a few thousand freelancing?

Probably not. If your self-employed turnover is £1,000 or less you may not need to report it at all under the trading allowance. Above that, a single income stream with a few expenses is well within what HMRC’s online Self Assessment service is designed for. Put money aside for the bill as you go and you will be fine.

What happens if I miss the Self Assessment deadline?

A late return brings an automatic penalty, and further penalties and interest build if it stays outstanding. Paying late is charged separately from filing late. If you have already missed one, file as soon as you can rather than waiting, and speak to HMRC about the balance; the position almost always improves once the return is in.

Can I switch accountants part way through the year?

Yes. There is no need to wait for your year end. We ask your previous accountant for the handover information, pick up the next deadlines and set up the software. It is a normal part of onboarding and we arrange it rather than leaving it with you.

Is accounting software enough on its own?

Software keeps the records and files the returns. It does not tell you that your rolling turnover is approaching the VAT threshold, or how much you can reasonably take out this quarter, or whether a contract sits inside the off-payroll rules. We include FreeAgent or Xero and set it up, then answer the questions the software cannot.