Rated 5.0 on Google One fixed monthly fee, agreed in writing FreeAgent or Xero included Brixton, by appointment Looking after South London businesses since 2015

Side hustle tax: the bit everyone gets wrong is not the threshold

Most articles about tax on side income stop at the reporting threshold, which is the easy part. The harder part is what you do between now and the January after the work took off. Here is the order we would sort it in.

Published 5 November 2026

6 min read

Ryan Morton, FMAAT, Founder and Principal Accountant

Side hustle tax is one of the few things in tax where the rule itself is simple and the consequences of ignoring it are not. If you earn more than the trading allowance from work outside your job, you tell HMRC, register for Self Assessment, and file a return. Most people find that out within ten minutes of searching.

What they do not find out is the thing that actually causes the trouble. In our experience it is almost never the threshold. It is eighteen months of PayPal, Etsy, Stripe and personal current account transactions that nobody kept a record of, and a January deadline that arrives with no money set aside against it.

So this post skips the threshold argument and goes to the part that matters: what to do once you have accepted that the extra income counts, and when the side thing stops being a side thing.

The allowance is the easy part

HMRC’s position is not complicated. If your gross income from trading outside employment goes over the trading allowance in a tax year, you report it. The allowance applies once across everything you do, so photography at weekends plus a bit of design work plus whatever you sold through a marketplace all add into the same pot. The government has confirmed it is going up from April 2027, which helps smaller earners and changes nothing for anyone whose second line of work is growing.

Selling your own old things is different. Clearing a wardrobe is not trading. Buying things to sell on, making things to sell, or being paid for a service is.

Where people go wrong is treating the threshold as a yearly test they can apply in hindsight. You cannot keep decent records retrospectively. By the time you know you are over, the information you need is spread across three payment platforms, a personal bank account and a phone full of receipts you meant to photograph. The threshold tells you whether you report. It does not tell you what to report, and that is the bit that takes the Sunday night.

Two accounts, one folder, from today

If you take one thing away: separate the money now, even if you are nowhere near the threshold and even if the second line of work is three invoices a year.

A second bank account in your own name is enough to start. Everything from the side work goes in. Everything you buy for it comes out of it. You do not need a company, a bookkeeper or a system that takes a weekend to configure.

What this gives you in January is a single statement that answers the only two questions on the return: what came in, and what went out for the business. Without it you are reconstructing a year from memory, and people reconstructing from memory almost always understate their costs. They forget the materials, the stall fee, the software subscription, the use of home claim. They pay more tax than they needed to because the evidence is gone, not because the rules were against them.

Keep a folder on your phone for receipts and put things in it the day they happen. An hour a month beats an evening in January, and it is the same hour either way.

The January bill that nobody budgets for

Here is the pattern we see most. Someone has a good first year, earns a few thousand on the side, spends most of it, files in January and gets a bill they were not expecting. Then they find out about payments on account.

If your Self Assessment bill is over £1,000 and less than 80% of your tax is already collected through PAYE, HMRC asks for payments on account towards the following year. In plain terms, that first January can ask for roughly one and a half times the tax you owe: the bill itself, plus half of next year’s on top. The second instalment follows in July.

It is not an extra tax. It is timing. But it is the single most common reason somebody rings us in a panic, and it hits hardest in the first year because nobody warned them.

The fix is unglamorous. Move a percentage of every payment that lands into a savings account the day it arrives and do not touch it. Your employment already has tax taken at source; the side income does not, and the rate it is taxed at depends on what your salary has already used up. If you cannot pay when the time comes, HMRC’s Time to Pay arrangements exist and are worth asking about early rather than late.

When the side thing stops being a side thing

At some point the question changes. It stops being how to report and starts being how to structure.

Three signs it has happened. You are turning down work because of capacity. The income is a meaningful part of what you live on. Or your rolling twelve-month turnover is heading towards the £90,000 VAT threshold, which is a rolling figure and not a tax-year one, so it can arrive in the middle of a quarter without any announcement.

That is also when sole trader or limited company becomes a real question rather than an internet one. A limited company brings filing dates, payroll decisions and rules about taking money out that did not apply before. It suits some people well and is a lot of admin for others. It depends on how much you are earning, how much of it you need to live on, and whether you have an employer contract that limits what you can do on the side.

There is also Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, which is phasing in by qualifying income over the next couple of years. If your side work keeps growing, keeping digital records now means that lands as a non-event rather than a scramble.

What we would actually do first

If you came to us with a job and a side income that has grown past comfortable, the order would be this.

  • Work out what you have actually earned from it over the last twelve months, gross, before costs. Not what you think. What the statements say.
  • Open a separate account and start running everything through it, even mid-year.
  • Register for Self Assessment if you have passed the allowance, and note the dates: the 5 October registration deadline after the tax year ends, then 31 January to file and pay.
  • Start setting aside a fixed percentage of each payment.
  • Only then ask whether the structure should change.

That last point matters. People reach for a company first because it feels like the grown-up thing to do, and then spend six months on filings they did not need yet. Get the records straight, see a full year of real numbers, then decide.

If you are already a limited company and it grew faster than planned, the same logic applies in a different order. Company money stays company money, transfers out get labelled as salary, dividend or expense, and director’s loans get spotted before the year end rather than after it.

Common questions

Do I pay side hustle tax if I already pay tax through PAYE?

Yes, if the extra income takes you past the trading allowance. Your employment tax is collected at source, but side income is not, so you report it through Self Assessment. The rate depends on what your salary has already used of your personal allowance and basic rate band, which is why the bill can be higher than people expect.

When does side hustle tax have to be registered and paid?

If you crossed the threshold in a tax year, you register by 5 October after that tax year ends, then file online and pay any tax due by 31 January. Miss the registration date and you can still file, but penalties and interest may follow. The earlier you register, the less of a scramble January becomes.

Does selling things on Vinted or eBay count as trading?

Clearing out your own belongings normally does not. Buying things specifically to sell on, making things to sell, or being paid for a service generally does. The test is whether you are trading rather than tidying. If you are doing it regularly and with a view to profit, assume it counts and keep records.

Should I set up a limited company for my side income?

Usually not in the first year. A company brings its own filing dates, payroll decisions and rules about taking money out. It becomes worth looking at when the income is substantial, steady, and more than you need to draw out to live on. Get one clean year of figures first, then decide.

What records do I actually need to keep?

Everything that came in, everything that went out for the business, and the evidence behind both. Bank statements from a separate account, invoices you issued, receipts for materials, equipment, software and travel. HMRC expects full and accurate records, and the practical benefit is that you claim the costs you are entitled to rather than the ones you can remember.