Rated 5.0 on Google One fixed monthly fee, agreed in writing FreeAgent or Xero included Brixton, by appointment Looking after South London businesses since 2015

Accounting software for small business: the one you will actually open

Most of the comparison articles you will find rank features you will never use. Our view is simpler, and it has more to do with your bank feed and your habits than with the brand on the login screen.

Published 5 November 2026

7 min read

Ryan Morton, FMAAT, Founder and Principal Accountant

Accounting software for small business owners usually gets chosen in a hurry, somewhere between the first big invoice and the first brown envelope. Someone at a co-working desk says they use one thing, a bank offers another for nothing, and the decision gets made in ten minutes on a Tuesday.

Our view, after ten years of picking up other people’s files, is that the choice between the main products matters far less than people think. They all raise an invoice. They all take a bank feed. They all file a VAT return. What separates a clean set of books from a shoebox is whether the thing was set up properly on day one, and whether you open it more than once a quarter.

So here is what the software is for, what Making Tax Digital has done to the shortlist, and how we would choose.

What the software is actually for

Strip out the marketing and the job is small. The software keeps a record of every pound in and out, links to your business bank account so most of those records arrive without you typing them, raises invoices that look like a company raised them, and sends your VAT return straight to HMRC under Making Tax Digital.

It also holds the evidence. Sole traders have to keep business records for five years after the 31 January filing deadline for that tax year, and companies keep theirs for six years from the end of the accounting period. A drawer of fading receipts technically counts. A photograph attached to the transaction it belongs to is a great deal easier to find when somebody asks.

What the software does not do is decide anything. It will happily let you record a dividend as wages, claim a flight to a holiday as travel, or sit at the wrong VAT scheme all year. It records what you tell it. That is worth remembering when a product promises to do your accounts for you.

Making Tax Digital narrowed the field

VAT-registered businesses have been filing digitally for a while. The bigger change lands on 6 April 2026, when sole traders with self-employment income above £50,000 have to keep digital records and send HMRC a quarterly summary of income and expenses, using software on HMRC’s compatible list. The quarterly updates are summaries rather than tax returns, and the return itself still goes in by the following 31 January.

Two practical things follow. First, pick the software before you sign up for the new regime, not after. Second, free products are a shorter list than they look, because many of them are not compatible and plenty have no bank feed, which is the feature that saves you the most time.

If you are self-employed and anywhere near that line, this is the year to stop running the business from a spreadsheet and a current account. It is also the year a fair number of people ask whether a company would suit them better, which is a separate question we work through on our sole trader accountants page.

The product is rarely the problem. Almost every tangled file we are handed started the same way: a bank feed nobody linked, and a personal card quietly paying for business things.

Where FreeAgent and Xero differ

We set clients up on FreeAgent or Xero, and the choice usually comes down to how many people touch the books.

FreeAgent suits one or two person companies, freelancers and contractors. It was built for them, the layout makes sense to someone who has never seen a ledger, and it shows a running view of what you owe rather than hiding it behind a report. Several banks include it with a business account, which is a fair reason to start there.

Xero earns its place once there is a bit more going on: a studio with staff and payroll, a practice running several projects at once, a few hundred transactions a month, invoices in more than one currency. It asks more of you in the first fortnight and it rewards the effort. The honest caveat is that it was designed with accountants in the room, and some of the language, particularly around how directors take money out, reads as though you already know the answer.

Neither is wrong. Both are on the compatible list. We would rather set you up on the one your accountant uses every day than the one that won a review.

How we would make the choice

Three questions settle it in most conversations.

  • Does your accountant work in it daily? Someone who knows the product can look at your file while you are on the phone and tell you what is wrong with it. Someone learning it on your time cannot.
  • Will your bank feed connect cleanly? A feed that drops every fortnight turns the whole thing into manual data entry with extra steps.
  • Will you open it? The product you tolerate beats the powerful one you avoid. If reconciling feels like homework, you will do it in March for the whole year, and that is where errors breed.

What we would not do is choose on price alone. The licence is a small part of what running a company costs, and the money saved on a free product gets spent putting the year right. Our own fee includes FreeAgent or Xero, set up with the bank feed linked and the routine shown to you, so the comparison rarely comes up.

One more thing worth doing before any of it: open a separate business bank account. It makes everything after it simpler.

The set-up is where it goes wrong

When a new client arrives with an existing file, the same handful of things are usually waiting in it.

The opening balances were never entered, so the first year reads as though the business began with nothing. The personal card is quietly paying for business things and nobody has recorded it. The VAT scheme is set to standard when the business is on flat rate, or the other way round. Dividends are sitting in the wages account, which makes the payroll figures wrong and the director’s own return harder than it needs to be. Receipts have been photographed diligently and matched to nothing.

None of that is a disaster, and we have never once told someone their file was beyond saving. It does take an afternoon to unpick, and the person who then has to explain the numbers in a set of annual accounts would rather it had been right from the start. Keep an eye on turnover as well. The registration threshold is a rolling twelve month figure, so you can cross £90,000 in a quiet month without noticing, and the software will not tell you unless somebody is looking.

Common questions

Which accounting software for small business do you set up for clients?

FreeAgent or Xero, included in the monthly fee. We configure it, link the bank feed, set the right VAT scheme and show you how to raise an invoice and run the day to day in it. Which of the two depends on whether you have staff and payroll, and on how much invoicing goes through the business.

Is free accounting software for small business owners good enough?

Sometimes, if you are small and the product is on HMRC’s compatible list. The catch is usually the bank feed. Free plans often leave you typing transactions in by hand, which is where mistakes start. Some banks include a paid product with a business account, which is a better free than most free plans.

Do I still need an accountant if the software does the sums?

The software records what you tell it and files what you approve. It will not query a dividend recorded as salary, spot that you are drifting over the VAT threshold, or tell you what you can sensibly take out of the company this year. That is the part a person does, along with the filings themselves.

Can I move from spreadsheets part way through the year?

Yes, and most people do. We enter the opening position, bring the bank in from the start of your accounting period and carry on from there. There is no need to wait for a year end. The same goes if you are moving from another accountant, since we arrange the handover during onboarding.

Where we stand

Choosing accounting software for small business owners is a twenty minute decision that people spend a fortnight on. FreeAgent if it is you, or you and one other. Xero if there are staff, payroll, or a real volume of invoices. Either way, on HMRC’s compatible list, with the bank feed linked and a separate business account behind it.

The part that actually decides how your year goes is the set-up, and then somebody checking it while the year is still fixable. If your books are a few months behind, or you are coming up to the April 2026 change and would rather not work it out yourself, that is the ordinary week’s work here. Our sole trader accountants page is a sensible place to start, or answer a few quick questions and we will come back with a plain recommendation.