Rated 5.0 on Google One fixed monthly fee, agreed in writing FreeAgent or Xero included Brixton, by appointment Looking after South London businesses since 2015

Off payroll working: how to read a status decision without panicking

Most contractors meet these rules as a line in an email from an agency, usually a fortnight before the contract starts. Here is what the decision actually does to your money, what it does not touch, and why the April 2026 change is worth a diary note.

Published 5 November 2026

6 min read

Ryan Morton, FMAAT, Founder and Principal Accountant

Off payroll working is the set of rules that decide whether the money your client pays your company should have tax taken off it first, as though you were on their payroll. The rules have been around since 2000 and most people still call them IR35. The name matters less than the question underneath: if you took the lanyard off and did the same job directly for the client, would an inspector call you an employee.

Our view, after a lot of these conversations across a kitchen table or a video call, is that the determination itself is rarely the crisis. What causes trouble is a contractor who gets the email, signs it without reading, and then finds the first payment is thousands lighter than the spreadsheet said. The rules are survivable. The surprise is not.

So here is how we read one of these decisions, what it changes in your company, and the bit of the calendar worth watching.

Who actually makes the decision

For most private sector contracts, the client decides. They look at how the work really runs, write down the answer and the reasons, and send it to you. That document is a status determination statement, and you are entitled to one before the work starts. If an agency sits between you and the client, the agency is usually the one deducting tax when the answer is inside.

There is an exception that catches people out, and it is the one worth knowing. If the client is a small company in the private sector, the decision bounces back to you. Your own limited company has to work out the status and account for the tax if the answer is inside. Plenty of contractors assume no determination arrived because there is nothing to worry about. Sometimes it means the opposite: the client is small, so it is your call and your liability.

HMRC’s own explainer on understanding off-payroll working sets out who carries the responsibility in each case. Worth ten minutes before you sign anything. If you are not sure which bucket your client sits in, ask them directly. It is a fair question and they should know the answer.

The three things a decision really turns on

Status is judged on how the engagement works in practice, not on the heading at the top of the contract. Three factors do most of the heavy lifting.

  • Control. Does the client tell you how and when to do the work, or do they tell you what they need and leave the method to you. A developer given a ticket and a deadline looks different from one sitting in the daily stand-up taking instructions.
  • Substitution. If you were ill for a fortnight, could you send a suitably qualified person in your place and would the client have to accept them. A clause saying yes is worth very little if everyone involved knows it would never happen.
  • Mutuality. Is the client obliged to keep finding you work when the project ends, and are you obliged to take it.

After that come the quieter signals: whose laptop you use, whether you carry any financial risk, whether you have other clients, whether you are on the internal org chart and invited to the Christmas party. None of them decides it alone. An inspector stands back and looks at the whole picture.

One point that gets muddled constantly. These rules only exist where there is an intermediary, usually your own personal service company. If you invoice as a sole trader, off-payroll does not apply to that engagement, though other agency rules can.

A client reclassifying as small is a reason to look at the contract again, not a reason to assume the answer flipped. The work either looks like employment or it does not.

What an inside decision does to your money

If the answer is inside, the party paying your company deducts income tax and employee National Insurance before the money reaches you, and pays employer National Insurance on top. The cash that lands in your business account is net. You do not pay corporation tax on it again, and you do not take it out as dividends, because the tax has already been settled.

Two practical consequences we see every time. First, travel and subsistence between home and that client site generally stop being claimable, which hurts more than people expect on a long commute into town. Second, student loan repayments are not deducted by the fee payer, so if you have one, it comes back round on your self assessment return in January. Budget for it rather than meeting it at the worst possible moment.

Your company does not have to close. Plenty of our clients run one contract inside and another outside in the same year, because the rules apply contract by contract, not to you as a person. The company keeps filing accounts, keeps its corporation tax obligations on any other income, and keeps its confirmation statement. The bookkeeping just needs to separate the two streams properly, which is the part people get wrong when they are doing it alone on a Sunday night.

The April 2026 threshold change

From 6 April 2026, the financial limits that define a small company go up. That sounds like dull accounting housekeeping, and for most businesses it is. For contractors it has a direct effect: some clients who currently have to issue determinations will be classed as small from the 2026 to 2027 tax year, and the responsibility moves back to the contractor’s own company.

If that happens to one of your clients, the practical change is that nobody sends you a determination any more. The decision, and the risk attached to it, is yours. Some contractors will be pleased about that. The ones who should not be are those who have been inside on a contract for two years, suddenly find themselves deciding their own status on the same working arrangement, and decide it is outside without anything about the job changing.

Our take: a client reclassifying as small is a reason to look at the contract again, not a reason to assume the answer flipped. The work either looks like employment or it does not, and a change in the client’s balance sheet does not alter how the job runs day to day. Keep the old determinations, keep the emails, and write down your reasoning at the time rather than reconstructing it two years later when somebody asks.

What we tell contractors to do before signing

Read the determination properly, including the reasons. If the reasoning does not match how you will actually work, say so before the contract starts. You have the right to challenge it, and a client who has taken reasonable care will usually engage with a specific, calm objection. A vague complaint that it feels unfair will not go anywhere.

Then do the arithmetic on the real number. An inside day rate and an outside day rate are not comparable figures, and we would rather you found that out before you committed than after the first payment. Factor in employer National Insurance if the rate is quoted as an umbrella or assignment rate, because that comes out of the same pot.

Keep the paperwork. The determination, the contract, the email thread where the client described the working arrangements. If HMRC ever looks, a tidy file from the time is worth far more than a confident memory.

And if you are setting up before your first invoice, get the order right: the company, the bank account, PAYE and VAT if relevant, and the status question answered before work starts rather than after. That is the bulk of what our contractor accountants work covers in the first fortnight with a new client.

Common questions

Does off payroll working mean I have to close my limited company?

No. The rules apply contract by contract, so you can be inside on one engagement and outside on another in the same year. The company carries on filing accounts, corporation tax and its confirmation statement. What changes is how money from that particular contract reaches you and how it is recorded in the books.

What happens if my client never sends a status determination statement?

Ask for one. If the client is medium or large in the private sector, they are required to determine your status and give you the reasons before the work starts. If they are a small company, there will not be one, because the decision sits with your own company instead. Either way, you want the answer in writing before you invoice.

Can I challenge an off payroll working decision I think is wrong?

Yes. There is a disagreement process, and the client has to consider your points and respond. Make it specific: point to the parts of the working arrangement that do not match their reasoning, such as how the work is scheduled or whether a substitute could genuinely be sent. A general objection rarely moves anyone.

Do the rules apply if I work through an umbrella company?

Usually not, because an umbrella company employs you directly and runs PAYE on your pay. Separate rules arriving in April 2026 put more responsibility on agencies and end clients to check umbrella PAYE is operated correctly. If you are weighing an umbrella against your own company, the comparison is about take-home and admin, not about these rules.

I was inside last year and outside now. Is that a problem?

Not by itself. Different contracts have different terms and different working arrangements, and HMRC accepts that. What matters is that each decision was reasonable at the time, based on how that engagement actually ran. Keep the determinations and the contracts so you can show the reasoning rather than recalling it later.

Our take

Off payroll working is a question about one contract at a time, answered by looking at how the job really runs. Most contractors we speak to are in a clearer position than they feared, once someone has actually read the determination with them and done the sums on what reaches the bank. The ones who get hurt are the ones who never looked.

If you have a determination sitting in your inbox and you are not sure whether to accept it, or a client who might fall below the new size limits in April, that is a normal conversation for us. We look at the contract, tell you plainly what we think and why, and handle the company side either way on one fixed monthly fee agreed in writing before we start. Our contractor accountants page sets out what that covers.