Rated 5.0 on Google One fixed monthly fee, agreed in writing FreeAgent or Xero included Brixton, by appointment Looking after South London businesses since 2015

What is IR35, in plain English

This guide is for contractors, interims and consultants working through their own limited company, and for anyone about to sign a first contract. It covers who decides your status, what inside and outside mean for the money that reaches your bank account, and what to do when a determination looks wrong. Around ten minutes to read.

The short version

  • IR35 asks one question: if you worked for this client directly, with no company in between, would you be an employee?
  • The answer is decided contract by contract. One engagement can sit inside the rules while another sits outside.
  • Medium and large private sector clients make the decision and must give you a written status determination statement.
  • Where the client is small, the decision and the tax risk stay with your own company.
  • How you actually work matters more than how the contract is worded, so the two need to match.

What IR35 is for

What is IR35 comes up the moment a contract lands and someone mentions a status determination. It is the common name for the off-payroll working rules, and it exists to stop the same job being taxed two different ways depending on whether there is a limited company sitting in the middle. HMRC’s position is that a worker who would have been an employee if hired directly should pay broadly the same income tax and National Insurance as that employee.

The rules have been with us since the Finance Act 2000, and they were rewritten for the public sector in 2017 and for the private sector in April 2021. That 2021 change is the one most contractors feel, because it moved the decision from the contractor to the client in most engagements.

None of this changes your rights at work. A contract can be inside the rules for tax and still give you no holiday pay, no sick pay and no notice period. It is a tax test, nothing more.

Below: who decides, what the decision is actually based on, what inside and outside mean for the money, and what to do when a determination looks wrong. HMRC’s own overview sits at gov.uk if you want the formal version alongside.

Who decides your status now

Before April 2021 in the private sector, the contractor’s own company made the call. Now it depends on the size of the end client.

Medium and large clients

The client assesses each engagement, takes reasonable care doing it, and issues a status determination statement (an SDS) before the first payment. The SDS has to give reasons, not just a verdict, and it has to reach you and any agency in the chain. The client must also run a process for you to disagree with it.

If the client decides the engagement is inside the rules, the fee payer (the client or the agency paying your company) deducts PAYE and employee National Insurance from your invoice before the money reaches you, and pays employer National Insurance on top. Where a client fails to take reasonable care or never issues an SDS, HMRC can move the tax liability back up the chain to them.

Small clients

Small private sector clients are outside the 2021 reforms. If your end client is small, the original rules still apply and your own limited company decides its status and carries the tax risk. This catches people out, because the client often says nothing at all, which can feel like a clean bill of health and is not one.

The size test uses turnover, balance sheet total and headcount, measured against the previous financial year. Two of the three thresholds rise from 6 April 2026, so some clients who issue determinations today will stop doing so, and the decision will land back on the contractor. Because the test looks backwards a year, that shift bites from April 2027 in most cases.

What the decision actually turns on

HMRC builds what it calls a hypothetical contract: strip out your company, imagine you and the client dealing directly, and ask what that relationship would look like to an employment tribunal. A handful of factors carry most of the weight.

Control

Does the client decide what you do, how you do it, when and where? A contractor is engaged to deliver a defined piece of work and brings their own method. Being told to attend the 9am stand up and work the client’s hours from the client’s desk pulls hard the other way.

Substitution

If you were unavailable, could your company send someone else of equivalent skill and pay them? A genuine right of substitution is a strong sign the client is buying a service rather than a person. A clause that exists on paper but that the client would never accept in practice counts for very little.

Mutuality of obligation

Is the client obliged to keep offering you work, and are you obliged to take it? Employees have that ongoing arrangement. A contractor finishes the project and both sides walk away with nothing owed.

Being in business on your own account

Other clients, your own equipment, your own insurance, fixing defects at your own cost, quoting for work, taking financial risk. None of these decides the case alone, and together they paint a picture.

What they do not include is how long you have been there, or what your day rate is. A long engagement is not automatically inside the rules, though a five year stint sitting in the same team doing the same job as the permanent staff will be a hard one to argue.

Inside or outside: what changes

The labels sound abstract until payday.

Outside IR35

Your company invoices, the full amount arrives, and you run the business normally. Corporation tax on the profit, a salary through payroll, dividends from what is left, business expenses claimed in the usual way. You decide the timing of what you take out. See how money comes out of a limited company for the mechanics.

Inside IR35

Where the client is medium or large, income tax and employee National Insurance come off before your company is paid, with student loan repayments deducted too where they apply. The money that reaches your company account has already been taxed, so there is no second bite when you draw it, and the usual contractor expense claims largely disappear.

Where the client is small and your company makes the decision, the company works out a deemed employment payment at the end of the tax year and runs the tax through payroll itself.

The gap between them

Contractor sites commonly estimate a drop of around a fifth to a third in take home pay on an inside engagement compared with an outside one at the same headline rate. That is a modelled range rather than an HMRC figure, and your own number depends on your rate, your other income and the rest of your tax position. The practical point: a day rate quoted without saying which side of the line it sits on tells you almost nothing.

Plenty of people run both in the same year, with one inside contract and one outside. That is fine. It just means two sets of numbers to keep straight, and it is worth having someone who deals with What is IR35 questions week in week out looking at the pair of them.

CEST, contracts and working practices

HMRC publishes a free tool, Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST), and most clients use it. It was rewritten in April 2025 with plainer wording and fuller guidance. HMRC says it will stand by the result where the answers entered genuinely reflect how the work is done.

Two things to know about it. First, it frequently returns “unable to determine”, which leaves the client exactly where they started. Second, it does not test every factor the courts look at, and its treatment of mutuality of obligation has been criticised in status tribunals. A CEST output is evidence, not a verdict.

Paper versus practice

This is where most enquiries are won or lost. HMRC looks at how the engagement actually ran, then checks whether the contract describes it. A substitution clause nobody would honour, a “no obligation to provide work” line in a contract where you have been told to book holiday through the client’s HR system: inconsistencies like that do real damage.

It also works the other way. If you have never had a signed contract, that is not a defence. HMRC will construct the hypothetical contract from the arrangements that plainly existed.

Keeping the evidence

Keep the SDS and the reasoning behind it. Keep emails showing you turned down extra work, worked where you chose, or fixed something at your own cost. Keep a note of other clients you had running at the same time. Independent contract reviews are widely available, and some contractors take out insurance covering representation and tax in an enquiry. HMRC’s compliance work in this area is continuing, and the government confirmed in July 2026 that there will be no review of the rules, so this is the landscape for the foreseeable future.

Setting up with IR35 in mind

Most people meet these rules with a client already lined up and no company to invoice from. The order you do things in matters less than doing all of them before the first invoice goes out.

A limited company is still the right vehicle for most contractors, including those expecting a mix of inside and outside work. You can form one through Companies House in a day. Where everything you do is inside the rules and you have no intention of building anything beyond the contract, an umbrella arrangement may be the simpler route, and we have set out the trade offs in our guide on Umbrella company vs limited company.

The practical list

  • Register for PAYE so you can run a salary, whichever side of the line you end up on.
  • Decide on VAT. Registration is compulsory once taxable turnover passes the £90,000 threshold on a rolling twelve month basis, and plenty of contractors cross it in their first year without noticing.
  • Ask the client, before you sign, whether they consider themselves small for these rules and whether an SDS is coming.
  • Get the contract read alongside a description of how the work will really run.
  • Set the company up in FreeAgent or Xero so the invoices, the deductions and the tax set aside are visible as you go rather than reconstructed in January.

Corporation tax, the confirmation statement and your own self assessment all follow from there. The corporation tax rules and the self assessment deadlines are published and fixed, which at least makes that part of the year predictable.

  1. —
  2. —
  3. —
  4. —
  5. —
  6. —

  • —
  • —
  • —
  • —